What is the double empathy problem?

"Double Empathy Problem at Work Examples" above a mirror selfie of a person bent forward with their head down and dark hair hanging over their face, holding a glittery cat-ear ring phone case up in front of them, with a door and hallway behind them.

Disability discrimination against autistic people is subtle.

From a non-autistic perspective, it doesn’t look, feel or sound like discrimination.

The discrimination most often originates from

  • the double empathy problem
  • ignorance about autistic traits
  • expecting neuronormativity,
  • and ableism.

But almost every form of discrimination against autistic people could be resolved via bridging the double empathy gap.

The double empathy problem is when people with different life experiences and ways of perceiving the world try to interact — like between autistic and non-autistic (allistic) people.

Note: Research on the double empathy problem centers around autistic vs. non-autistic relations.

However, you can apply the double empathy problem to almost any differing groups of people struggling to understand each other due to communicative, experiential and social differences.

⚡ Please consider other marginalized groups of people when reading/referencing this post as well.

Perceiving directness as aggression or hostility

One of the most common, damaging examples of the double empathy problem is an autistic person’s literal, direct communication style perceived as aggressive/hostile.

It happens due to non-autistic culture valuing politeness and hedging over direct, literal presentation of information.

  • An autistic employee may be reprimanded for how they said something, not what they said.
  • A non-autistic employee’s abusive behavior may be excused because they managed to explain what happened in a neuronormative tone, even if the autistic employee can prove the abuse.

Tone-policing is a form of microaggression and discrimination, especially when enacted against a marginalized group. While typically applied to racial discussions, tone-policing happens to autistic people, too.

Non-autistic culture relies on social padding to avoid conflict. Instead of being direct, allistics aim to say what they want to say without explicitly saying it.

Workplace discrimination

In the workplace, this could more directly be differentiated as

  • Allistic communication most often relies heavily on plausible deniability through indirectness, allowing passive-aggressive behavior to avoid social “blame” for being perceived as confrontational or rude.
  • Autistic communication most often relies on directness without ulterior motives, meaning they rarely perceive others as having ulterior motives. We don’t think ahead as, like, “How can we use this?”

Allistic employees without enough positive relationship developments with autistic people will assume autistic employees are communicating through a deniability lens.

So when an autistic employee shares a truth directly, the allistic employee will interpret the genuine honesty as a deliberate choice to strip the social padding.

But because allistic culture = social padding is stripped to be hostile or dominant, the allistic will falsely conclude the autistic person is being aggressive or threatening.

This collision acts as a primary catalyst for systemic workplace discrimination against autistic employees.

Allistic management will think the autistic employee has an attitude problem and/or is unmanageable and write them up, because neuronormativity = organic neurodivergent difference is treated as a voluntary choice to be difficult.

Neuro-aware management would be conscious of this behavior as punishing the autistic employee for their disability.

Quinn looking content, resting her head on her hands, resting her hands on a row of books at the library
© Heartbreak High

Heartbreak High’s Quinni is a great example of this:

  • Sasha breaks up with Quinni due to Quinni being “a lot”, “pulling the f*cking autism card”, and wanting to be a “normal teenager”.
  • Quinni is dumped for engaging in her autistic special interests, expressing autistic joy, got told she was “pulling the autism card” when she realized Sasha was dumping her for not being “normal enough”, and had her entire autistic experience reduced to being too much for someone else to deal with.
  • Sasha attempts to retract, saying that’s not what she meant.
  • Quinni leaves, because the damage has been done.

This is the same collision.

It could even be an allistic person thinking an autistic person is playing a game with hidden meanings, annoyed with the autistic for “playing dumb”.

Or an allistic person perceiving an autistic’s direct, literal diction as “threatening”.

Allistic people are often not aware of their passive aggression or controlling behaviors, because this neurotypical behavior is the default “normal”.

It’s still the double empathy problem, and it’s still a $180 billion problem.

But this kind of judgment is also related to something else:

Thin-slice judgments

Tortie kitten looking towards camera while laying on white blanket, seemingly posed

A consequence of the double empathy problem, thin-slice judgments are split-second social conclusions formed based on

  • attire
  • eye contact
  • facial expressions
  • gestures
  • posture

The list goes on.

A thin-slice judgment is a byproduct of the double empathy problem and another way people punish autistic people for their autism.

In 2017, University of Texas researchers found allistic people formed thin-slice judgments about autistic people in response to noticing signs of autism within a few seconds, regardless of age. A few patterns:

  • Allistic people had negative impressions of autistics within a few seconds of meeting the autistics, often before they even spoke.
  • Negative impressions included judgments of attractiveness and likeability, though submissiveness was perceived more positively.
  • Thin-slice judgments weren’t changed by repeated interactions with the autistic person.
  • They preferred to cut contact with the autistic person entirely.

In other words, non-autistic people have an inherent bias against autistic people that makes them reject autistic people due to autistic behavioral differences.

Self-regulatory behaviors like stimming, for example, are perceived as lying.

Stereotyped assumptions were more likely to change through meaningful interactions with the autistic person, but allistics favored rejecting autistic people entirely.

This means autistic people are at an immediate disadvantage in the workplace.

However, because of the double empathy problem and frequent lack of positive neurodiversity training, human resources departments are incapable of recognizing discrimination against autistic people by default.

By the time an autistic employee recognizes their workplace reports are being dismissed due to the double empathy problem, it’s too late: the damage has been done, trust is irreparable, and legal rights are their last systemic resort for resolution.

Perceived insubordination due to rejecting social games

Bathroom mirror selfie, face covered by phone

What it looks like in practice:

  • Answering rhetorical, sarcastic and/or trapping questions literally
  • Bypassing the “chain of command” for efficiency
  • Declining performative agreeableness/socializing
  • Refusing to validate a bad idea
  • Rejecting gossip/drama
  • Requesting clarity in writing
  • Using precise terminology, rather than relying on ambiguity

Allistics perceive these behaviors as

  • “actively refusing to engage with the team”
  • “being argumentative”
  • “being smart”
  • “challenging every directive”
  • “defiant”
  • “defiant of company culture”
  • “difficult to manage”
  • “going over their head”
  • “publicly undermining leadership”
  • “refusing to respect authority”
  • “seeking special favors”
  • “showing blatant disrespect”
  • “superiority complex”
  • “talking back”
  • “uncooperative”
  • “wanting special treatment”

Without realizing they are microaggressions against natural autistic behavior — and, honestly, other marginalized demographics.

Facial constructive discharge failures prove lack of double empathy

Management’s most common solution to getting rid of autistic employees is making the workplace environment unworkable via emotional abuse, falsified records, isolation, micromanagement, and an unsafe workplace environment no reasonable human being would remain in.

Attempts to manage an autistic employee out, however, demonstrates the Dunning-Kruger effect.

If management had had double empathy, they would not have perceived the autistic employee as the problem in the first place.

If double empathy was not an issue, management would have foreseen the catastrophic issue with attempting to constructively discharge an autistic employee:

Pink border and white background reading "You cannot teach the double empathy problem to people who refuse to listen. Once the double empathy problem is diagnosed as the reason workplace reports fall flat, the autistic employee is confronted with the fact that internal resolution is impossible. And that it's a multi-billion-dollar problem for US employers," with key phrases highlighted in yellow and "lemonandlively.com" written along the curved edge at the top left.

The autistic employee does not immediately recognize what is happening (delayed processing and bottom-up thinking).

They do not catch the hints that they’re being pushed out (literal processing).

They do not understand being pushed out cannot be corrected internally (alexithymia).

So autistic employees keep pushing back.

It’s like when serial killers in Dexter get frustrated over their targets being difficult to murder.

The more an autistic person struggles to understand the WHY, the more they’re going to investigate (rumination, monotropism, looping, etc.).

And if an autistic person is out of work, they’ve got plenty of time to dig.

This is where an autistic’s natural communication style pays off. My communication style relies heavily on written communication.

Autistic people often document their knowledge/experiences/delayed processing by default, without intentionally building a paper trail.

Those without double empathy perceive this from an adversarial lens and assume this was the point the entire time. (Hanlon’s razor doesn’t matter when proving malicious intent, though.)

Most autistic adults are also diagnosed with severe trauma they endured as a result of being autistic, which means they grew up hypervigilant. Hypervigilance is triggered when survival mode is triggered.

Autistic people also often struggle with justice sensitivity, which is a strong, intense moral compass that drives them to prioritize equity and consistency over social hierarchies and unwritten rules.

Autistic traits paired with hypervigilance in survival mode mean the autistic employee with justice sensitivity cannot and will not be stopped until their employee file is legally sound.

Double empathy would have prevented this, because developing it forces people without it to unpack and work through their biases.

Many autistic employees spend months to years performing emotional labor to educate coworkers and supervisors about autism because of this.

Autistic self-advocacy is quite common, though employers have yet to account for the modern-day reality of outspoken disabled employees having platforms.

Which introduces and adds the Streisand effect to risk mitigation because seasoned advocacy bloggers know how to leverage their platforms.

See how it stacks?

Problem is, you cannot teach people without double empathy about double empathy if they do not want or care to listen.

You cannot teach anyone who has made thin-slice judgments about you about the double empathy problem if those thin-slice judgments turned into permanent assessments.

Therefore, by the time the autistic employee recognizes and diagnoses the double empathy problem is the reason for the discrimination in the first place, the employer has enacted irreparable systemic damage.

Due to pattern recognition, the autistic employee knows the pattern will repeat.

Double empathy built into company infrastructure is the only thing that can prevent this issue from occurring, because it will force management to recognize autistic employees’ desperate attempts to prevent external escalation for justice are not threats or insubordination.

It will force management to acknowledge the intersectionality between the employee and their autism, thus everything they bring with them to work.

And then apply the dismantling of their inherent biases against autistic people to other marginalized demographics, thus making inclusivity closer to the default instead of the afterthought (and avoiding double discrimination).

This analysis is an expansion of my 1st October, 2026 LinkedIn post.

P.S. Different types of stimming & why autistic people need routine

Love this post?

Support me by subscribing to my blog and/or buying me a cuppa:

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com/LemonAndLively

Leave a comment